Skip to content
PolyConsensus
← Traders

Compare traders

Two to four tracked traders side by side: their record on consensus markets, where they are strongest, what prices they buy at, how often they side with the consensus and the markets they hold together right now.

Traders side by side
Sardinianshepherdsainttroplaybeachboy4BreakTheBank
Record (consensus markets)68% (671–312, n=983)71% (10–4, n=14)68% (43–20, n=63)45% (526–640, n=1166)
Consensus PnL$81K$4.4M$5.8M$10.6M
Tracked asHand-pickedwas PM monthly #11was PM monthly #24PM monthly #1
Sides with the consensus64% (7 of 11 open)no open consensus position100% (1 of 1 open)74% (73 of 98 open)
Strongest topics
  • NHL +27 pts n=13, ROI +19%
  • Soccer +10 pts n=81, ROI +5%
  • NFL +50 pts n=123, ROI +50%
  • NBA +49 pts n=93, ROI +48%
  • Soccer +41 pts n=277, ROI +38%
Weakest topic——NBA −6 pts, n=92—
Settled positions, side won76% of 1255 at avg 70¢, ROI +7%100% of 10 at avg 49¢, ROI +52%57% of 212 at avg 54¢, ROI +3%98% of 539 at avg 53¢, ROI +41%
Entries under 30¢14% (won 12% of 170)0%3% (won 17% of 6)10% (won 85% of 53)
Entries 30–50¢9% (won 47% of 109)50% (won 100% of 5)29% (won 56% of 62)36% (won 98% of 192)
Entries 50–70¢13% (won 71% of 167)50% (won 100% of 5)54% (won 51% of 115)35% (won 99% of 187)
Entries 70¢ and up64% (won 94% of 809)0%14% (won 86% of 29)20% (won 100% of 107)

Records and specialties count consensus markets only and run optimistic: Polymarket's closed-position data rarely lists bets that went to zero. Edge = how much more often the held side won than its entry price implied.

Markets they hold together now

0 on the same side, 3 on opposite sides. Opposite sides first.

MarketSardinianshepherdsainttroplaybeachboy4BreakTheBank
Will the Democratic Party control the House after the 2026 Midterm elections?
opposite sides · consensus Yes
Yes $3.8K——No $184K
Will the Republicans win the Nebraska Senate race in 2026?
opposite sides · consensus Yes
No $175——Yes $38K
Will the Democrats win the Texas Senate race in 2026?
opposite sides · consensus Yes
Yes $2.5K——No $35K